menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
Feature Story

Features

Review: "Brag all you want! But don't get between me and DS9 Season 5!" - Plus, DVD Giveaway!

Features

By Steve Krutzler / 12:01, 28 September 2003 / TrekWeb Features

STAR TREK: DEEP SPACE NINE
Complete Fifth Season DVD Gift Set
7 discs, 26 episodes, 5 extras + 10 easter eggs
Retail: $99
Streets: October 9, 2003 (U.S.)

TrekWeb's Rating:


Purchase the set from any of the following merchants to help support TrekWeb:While it’s impossible to find a bad year of STAR TREK: DEEP SPACE NINE it’s probably possible to pick a best and, despite some spectacular storytelling in seasons six and seven, the title arguably belongs to season five. Unlike ST: TNG, which clearly showed signs of age by its fifth year, DS9 took off in startling new directions and by its end galvanized a hardcore group of NINE fans who would never look back. Plots became deeply involved as wars were fought, ended, and begun; characters transformed as unlikely romance flourished, genetic secrets were revealed, and powers were restored. Kirk and Spock guest starred, Robert Picardo stopped by, the crew got new uniforms, and even the Maquis got some comeuppance.

The year starts off well with “Apocalypse Rising,” wrapping up the ominous warning of season four’s “Broken Link” and giving us Sisko’s bellowing “brag all you want” line—probably one of the character’s best moments. Gritty war drama is the heart of “Nor the Battle to the Strong…” and even the infamous “Let He Who Is Without Sin…” tries to be about something.

The tribute episode “Trials and Tribble-ations” comes early in the season and it’s definitely one for the history books. They even got the original actor from the episode to appear 30 years later--Charlie Brill (‘Darvin’)--and Dax with a beehive and a miniskirt beats a catsuit any day. The effects shots of the Enterprise are just astounding and catching a glimpse of the original series with modern technology is breathtaking. The matching of classic footage is extremely well done, entirely convincing us that Sisko et al are occupying the same space as the classic actors. Celebrating “The Trouble With Tribbles” in such a fond manner with sets and costumes and visual effects that are completely top-notch, the self-congratulatory nostalgia is just the kind of thing to get you in a good mood and probably a great episode to show a friend who hasn’t been turned onto DS9 yet.

Season five also holds that singular hole in my own DS9 experience, that one episode I missed in 1996 and have since waited seven years to see for the first time. The fact that it centers on one of the show’s dynamic duos—Odo and Quark—makes it no surprise that “The Ascent” was worth the wait. This episode encapsulates all the great interplay between Rene Auberjonois and Armin Shimerman that we only rarely glimpsed (like in season four’s “Crossfire,” for instance), the camaraderie between thief and constable making “Ascent” a perfect example of what set DS9 apart from other TREK series and why it inspired so much loyalty in its fans.

Things pick up plot-wise as Odo gets his powers back in “The Begotten,” the Maquis and ‘Mister Eddington’ get a reprise in “For the Uniform” and “Blaze of Glory,” Doctor Bashir turns out to be a test-tube baby, and the Dominion arc heats up in “In Purgatory’s Shadow”/”By Inferno’s Light” and the explosive final “Call to Arms.” The finale is probably one of the best TREK episodes of all time and also one of the most different. Character is central here and Marc Alaimo and Jeffrey Combs solidify themselves as some of the greatest villains in TREK’s history in this episode. The notion that the heroes would actually lose at the end of this one just blew our minds and the closing shot was unlike anything we’d ever seen before. It’s probably safe to say “Call to Arms” made for the longest summer since TNG’s “The Best of Both Worlds.” Thank goodness we only have to wait a couple months for season six this time.

The Extras
The fifth season set’s five bonus featurettes follow the same pattern we’ve come to expect from these releases, blending some excellent presentations with a couple forgetful pieces. First off, two of the programs are devoted to “Tribble-ations,” providing an excellent behind-the-scenes record of the classic homage. Both UNITING TWO LEGENDS and AN HISTORIC ENDEAVOR are full of archival interview footage of the cast—Auberjonois, Farrell, Dorn, Brill—as well as plenty of old and new remarks from Behr, Moore, Echevarria, and even Berman. The episode is no doubt one of the STAR TREK’s very best and both documentaries do a superb job getting that point across. The only problem is they should’ve been joined together.

UNITING TWO LEGENDS mostly includes remarks on the writing process from the staff, as well as general statements from the actors. Behr relays his tale of coincidentally running into Charlie Brill in a pizza joint while the episode was being developed and segments with Moore and Echevarria retell their fan-like exuberance at writing it. HISTORIC ENDEAVOR takes a more technical approach, offering discussion from Herman Zimmerman on recreating the Enterprise sets with a faulty blueprint and visual effects supervisor Gary Hutzel on building new NCC-1701 and Station K-7 models. The tributes to the tribute are fun and insightful but there’s no reason they couldn’t have been merged, freeing up space for a documentary on the overall development of the season, which is surprisingly absent in this package.

The remaining three programs follow the DS9 DVD mold, with the season five installment of the by now far less interesting MICHAEL WESTMORE’S ALIENS, a profile of Mike Okuda’s graphics for the show in INSIDE DS9, and the CREW DOSSIER on ‘Miles O’Brien’. The first briefly mentions transforming the regulars into Klingons for the premiere, but no behind-the-scenes footage is offered and no discussion of crafting the Klingon looks for each individual actor is present either. Westmore talks then in general terms about the look of the Jem’Hadar and extending Terry Farrell’s spots down her legs to round out this 7-minute affair.

INSIDE DS9 is a pretty standard mix of old and new interview footage with artist Mike Okuda about the graphics around the station, but this feels particularly worn and generic. There is no specific focus on the work in season five and by now we’ve heard and seen enough of the “set graphic in-jokes” that have gone on over the various series that this just seems like something we’ve seen on previous DVDs. The dossier on Colm Meaney’s character is impressive, but unfortunately lacks any new footage with the actor. Wolfe, Farrell, and Moore talk about the Chief’s “every man” qualities and Meaney cites “Hard Time” as a particularly challenging performance in his footage from the spring of 1999, when the series has just about wrapped.

Disappointingly, the set doesn’t include any focused presentation on the development of season five, probably one of the most creatively fruitful and certainly important of the series. Numerous story arcs began or took major turns here (Worf and Dax, the Klingon war, the Dominion War, Odo’s powers, etc.) and yet we don’t hear anything about it from Ira Behr, Ron Moore, Robert Wolfe or anybody else. Some reflection on the daring move to kick off a major war with the season finale and maroon the crew off the station was certainly in order—did the staff have a plan for season six, or did they just throw caution to the wind, craft a stupendous final episode, and then head off to hiatus with no idea how it was going to resolve itself? What were the challenges on taking the show’s level of serialization to the point of no return? While the season two, three, and four sets provided plenty of discussion on the creative development in those years, we’ll have to hope that season six’s set will delve more deeply into the numerous developments of season five.

That said, again the SECTION 31 HIDDEN FILES steal the show. Easily the best bonus material aside from the “Tribble-ations” programs, all ten files offer very different material and some of the only glimpses at other episodes in the year. Numbers 1 and 2 offer new footage of Rene Auberjonois on “The Begotten” and “The Ascent;” The third tackles writer Robert Wolfe’s decision to leave after “Call to Arms;” Number four presents new footage of Nana Visitor reflecting on giving birth during the season, and she offers some interesting remarks on “Ties of Blood and Water” in the fifth hidden file.

File 06 features Ron Moore talking about “Soldiers of the Empire” and 07 offers a special look at “Doctor Bashir, I Presume?” with remarks from Chase Masterson. Eight features new footage of Armin Shimerman talking about the new actress for ‘Moogie’ (Cecily Adams); Nine contains actor J. G. Hertzler’s thoughts on “Soldiers,” and the final tenth file provides a brand new interview with Jeffrey Combs about eventually landing the role of the villainous ‘Weyoun’.

Rounding it all up is a nice photo gallery and the usual sturdy packaging that makes browsing the seven discs both pleasant and quick.

Final Thoughts
How can anyone not like STAR TREK: DEEP SPACE NINE? Really, season five begs the question. Even though the extra features aren’t five star quality (mainly owing to poor selection and organization of material), the 26-episodes filling these discs outweighs any shortcomings of a few documentaries you’ll probably only watch once or twice anyway. If you’re a DS9 fan, this is absolutely one set you must own. If you’ve never seen most of these episodes, you’d be a fool to miss out now. And if you can only own one season of DS9, you’d have a hard time finding any reason why season five shouldn’t be it—the first eight episodes of season six notwithstanding.

Season Five DVD Giveaway
TrekWeb is teaming up with Paramount Home Entertainment to give away the best of STAR TREK: DEEP SPACE NINE through the end of the year and beyond! We'll give away a FREE copy of the season five DVD set to one lucky winner every month for the next several months! All you have to do to qualify is be a subscriber to TrekWeb's News Nexus e-mail newsletter. In each month's issue we'll announce one lucky subscriber who will receive a FREE ST: DS9 season five DVD set (Region 1, but all visitors eligible).

Next month, we'll also be giving away five FREE copies of the upcoming STAR TREK V: THE FINAL FRONTIER Collector's Edition DVD, so if you aren't a News Nexus subscriber yet, join now for free!



More Top StoriesComments
Nov 21J.J. Abrams, Roberto Orci and Alex Kurtzman on Shatner and Nimoy4
Nov 21Roberto Orci on the Status of the Star Trek XII Script and the Possibility of Producing a New Star Trek TV Series13
Nov 205-Page Preview of Final Issue of Nero Comic Book Mini Series 4
Nov 20J.J. Abrams Says the Success of the DVD May Bring More People to Star Trek XII1
Nov 20Karl Urban Says is an Honor and Privilege to be Part of Star Trek, Talks Trek XII1
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

11 comments Post New | Help
View:

They probably had secret forces. | Report this post to moderator
By: Hbasm (Odo's file, contact) @ 13:15:57 on Sep 28, 2003

It has always been a mystery to me, how the show could change that much. The quality of season 5-7 was unbelieveably high, although few (if any?) important people behind the scenes were changed. How did they DO this!?

I can't help but to think, they got help from the prophets. From angels, as was symbolised in DS9 by the wormhole aliens. Normally, things don't work out THAT well for us humans. The rest of Star Trek, shows what to expect from mortals.

Possibly, something like the story in season 4 "The Muse" where Jake gets help writing his stories, occured in real life. I don't say it's a fact but I'm wondering when nobody tells me HOW THEY DID THIS.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
  • RE: They probably had secret forces. | Report this post to moderator
    By: Steve Krutzler (Odo's file, contact) @ 13:28:51 on Sep 28, 2003

    I really don't know what you're talking about if you think seasons three and four weren't excellent. Seasons one and two were pretty good but years three and four were just about as good as season five. There are so many good episodes in the first four years and seasons three and four are right in stride as well. I just think season five is sort of the apex.

    --------

    It's a rip-off. / We're stepped on, and cheated! / We're flat, stone-cold lied to / But we're not defeated / No!

    Halen. "The Dream is Over."


    Reply
    Reply
    Quote
    Quote
    • RE: They probably had secret forces. | Report this post to moderator
      By: Hbasm (Odo's file, contact) @ 13:56:44 on Sep 28, 2003

      No no sorry, you got me wrong. :) I loved the other seasons too. I was just talking about the striking difference between them.

      From 1-3 it was the usual quality of Star Trek (which I think is good) but then the show got hit by the lighting. Season 4 was a corner stone. It was an aggressive move. I felt almost every episode in season 4 was trying to be provocative in some way. It was a heavy shake-up. It settled down in season 5-7 which then turned out the most magnificent stories.


      Reply
      Reply
      Quote
      Quote
      • RE: They probably had secret forces. | Report this post to moderator
        By: Steve Krutzler (Odo's file, contact) @ 14:03:09 on Sep 28, 2003

        I don't know, I've watched all of seasons 1-4 in the last few months and I don't think there was any such major change at the beginning of the fourth season. All they did was bring in Worf and change the opening music. The show had already been provocative for the first three seasons. Look at episodes like "Duet" and "Necessary Evil" and "Past Tense" and "Improbable Cause"/"Die is Cast." Look at "The Jem'Hadar" and "The Adversary." No, I can't say season four was any "more" provocative than seasons 1-3. They brought on Worf and developed the Dominion arcs more, but the show was excellent in season two.

        --------

        It's a rip-off. / We're stepped on, and cheated! / We're flat, stone-cold lied to / But we're not defeated / No!

        Halen. "The Dream is Over."


        Reply
        Reply
        Quote
        Quote
        • RE: The changes... | Report this post to moderator
          By: Hbasm (Odo's file, contact) @ 14:46:31 on Sep 28, 2003

          Well, the episodes you mention are mildly provocative IMO. The people mostly talk and the audience thinks.

          In season 4, we had those knife battles in *several* episodes that changed my view of the crew. They were nolonger the nice people. We saw how Sisko, Dax, even O'Brien were capable of acting brutal to reach their goals. Until season 4, there was only one incident where Dax uses a Klingon sword for real.

          In season 4, there were also this episode with Dax kissing another woman. We had the story with Worf's brother Corn (if that's the correct spelling) and they decide to 'kill' his personal memories. That was a very questionable act too. We had the episode "Hard Time" that was very dark and unlike anything DS9 presented before (any Star Trek for that matter).

          In "Way of the Warrior" the tone was set for the rest of the season. Sisko was willing to cut his hand for the Klingons to see blood. Kira & Dax were in the holosuite running one of Quarks erotic programs. Worf gets drunk and sings with a fellow Klingon to get important information about the upcoming war.

          The opening scenes had usually been peaceful camera rolls somewhere on the station. Nomore! It was now Bashir beating someone up in the holosuite, so he crashes through a window / mirror. In short, everything got more aggressive.


          Reply
          Reply
          Quote
          Quote
          • RE: The changes... | Report this post to moderator
            By: Steve Krutzler (Odo's file, contact) @ 15:42:56 on Sep 28, 2003

            Hmm, perhaps there was more action per se, but I think you're just latching into superficial scenes and trying to glean some pattern from them. If I memorized the teasers for all the season 1-3 eps, I'm sure I could find plenty of "aggressive" beginnings, and those seasons certainly didn't lack for "questionable" ethics and "darkness." The show was dark and gritty from the beginning, hence why it turns so many people off at first.

            --------

            It's a rip-off. / We're stepped on, and cheated! / We're flat, stone-cold lied to / But we're not defeated / No!

            Halen. "The Dream is Over."


            Reply
            Reply
            Quote
            Quote
            • RE: The changes... | Report this post to moderator
              By: Hbasm (Odo's file, contact) @ 16:46:31 on Sep 28, 2003

              Well, who knows... As far as I remember, DS9 received a lot of hard criticism (like ENT does now) from fans up till season 4 began. Then opinions were reevaluated. I'm sure that season 4 was a deliberate attempt to shake up the audience, with more violence in the show. It worked for most people. I wasn't a regular visitor around here back then, but I remember some general change of attitudes. People called the show "awesome" and "constantly changing". In season 3, I remember one of the writers from DS9 said he was personally convinced that DS9 was "a great show although people don't understand".

              Personally I had a hard time through season 4 and was depressed by the development. I wrote some friendly and heartfelt letters to those involved with DS9. I was really worried with season 4. But it turned out I loved season 5 and beyond, for the most part. The knife-battles were gone. We got back to a sensible level where people were talking, and the audience thinking. Even though there was a war.


              Reply
              Reply
              Quote
              Quote
              • RE: The changes... | Report this post to moderator
                By: Daniel (Odo's file, contact) @ 20:50:14 on Sep 28, 2003

                sometimes harsh criticism of a Star Trek show is just for the simple fact that it doesn't seem to match people's expectations of what a Star Trek show is supposed to be. But with DS9, after a certain point, people started to see and understand what DS9 was all about and how great it was. I think that forces them - me at least - to re-evaluate everything that has come before. So, the harsh critics may have re-thought their original opions. I know I have. DS9 is now my favorite of the Star Treks.


                Reply
                Reply
                Quote
                Quote
                • Possible Changes | Report this post to moderator
                  By: Dukat (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 01:12:08 on Sep 30, 2003

                  I don't know if it was like turning a corner or anything like that-- There are outstanding episodes consistently throughtout all seven seasons. Season 4 was the point where it just became fantastic, kinda like the boots finally got really well broken in.

                  I do think that externally there were some factors on this. With the addition of Worf, it really did bring a new freshness, but unlike the Xindi, or Seven before that, the show did not really freak out over this addition.

                  Also with First Contact and Voyager happening, Paramount was completely engaged in other matters and DS9 was really left alone.

                  Lastly, I think it was about season 4 when I became aware of Ron D Moore's online Q&A's -- While I think paying too much attention to the online fanbase is dangerous, I always got the feeling like he understood what the issues were and cared, and probably took that back to Ira and the others too. If nothing else he could explain what was really going on or why things had to happen-- he did not treat the fans like dolts. (However, I wish he had not been so clear on how evil Dukat was, because I always liked thinking that Dukat was really a good hero, just not for our guys). I get the feeling with Berman & Braga they are aware of the net, but really have not spent the time to even try and understand what people are really complaining about.

                  --------

                  Image


                  Reply
                  Reply
                  Quote
                  Quote
  • RE: They probably had secret forces. | Report this post to moderator
    By: PokeTrek (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 13:26:48 on Sep 28, 2003

    Berman and Braga were too busy screwing up Voyager to try and tame DS9's brilliance. If I remember right, didn't Rob Wolfe leave during/after DS9's run?

    --------

    "I'm astounded that your organization [the MSHSAA] tries to regulate what these kids do in their free time. Would you tell them they couldn't watch Star Trek or eat potato chips?"
    -Missouri State Rep. Bryan Stevenson, R-Joplin


    Reply
    Reply
    Quote
    Quote

"Dax with a beehive and a miniskirt beats a catsuit any day." | Report this post to moderator
By: tomba1701 (Odo's file, contact) @ 12:35:51 on Sep 28, 2003


Amen to that Brother Steve! Best episode of what was arguably the best season of DS9! Classic episodes that built up to the incredible Dominion War arc of Season 6 and Season 7.

--------

"Commander, laws change, depending on who's making them. But justice, is justice" - Odo, "A Man Alone"


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
© 1996-2009 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.