|
|
Watching the birth of a new Star Trek fan ...
Website gets POed with Zoe Saldana...
TV Guide: Why Star Trek should return to TV.
STID Underperforming?! Is it time to release info in commercials?
J.J. IS THE MAN, GOTTA LOVE HIM !!!
It is important that we be humble and grateful (no spoilers)

Is INTO DARKNESS better than STAR TREK (2009)?. Is INTO DARKNESS better than STAR TREK (2009)?




By GustavoLeao / 20:11, 18 February 2013 / Trek Books
When I heard that one of my favorite Star Trek authors was coming out with another original series novel, I was thrilled. The premise starts off well with the crew of the Enterprise investigating a planet devoid of life, and finding a city in ruins. When they try to determine how long ago the civilization disappeared, they discover it was less than a year ago. Cue the spooky music.
At that point the story begins to fall apart, and it makes me wonder if George had a nifty idea for a short story and then tried to expand it to novel length. He gets the main characters spot on, but the minor characters don’t ring true. A conflict between Sulu and Kirk seems forced and not believable. Several references to previous episodes of the original TV series in both the live action and animated realms seem unnecessary, since these books tend to be read by fans.
A rare misfire.

(1)
![]() Reply |
![]() Quote |