menuBarBack
Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
News Story

Features

Roberto Orci Talks Briefly About Star Trek XII, Scotty and the Borg

Features

By GustavoLeao / 22:16, 5 October 2009 / Star Trek: Nemesis

Recently on the Don Murphy Message Board, Roberto Orci, one half of the dynamic duo that brought us the stories for the first two Transformers movies, confirmed that he and his partner, Alex Kurtzman, will not be scripting Transformers 3.

Orci implied that he and Kurtzman are hard at work on penning a sequel to their re-imagining of the Star Trek movie franchise. Here are a few of his posts at the message board.

Hey Bob.

You'll probably be starting on the Star Trek: Something Something script soon, so I'd like to suggest something!

Don't let Scotty become a caricature. I know he's played by Simon Pegg, but don't just let the character be the wacky, crazy Scottish man that everyone laughs at. Treat his character like a real person. Give us some depth! Simon can do serious, too.

I could kind of say that everyone but Kirk and Spork suffered from not having bits that make us care about them. Like, Bones and Sulu and Scotty and Chekov... can we learn something more about them? I know the first movie focused on the Kirk and Spock's stories, and that was a great decision, but everyone else matters too. Have them be integral (other than getting Kirk onto the Enterprise, Bones doesn't affect the story at all), and let us know some of their backstories. Show us that they have emotions. Look at it like it's an ensemble cast, with just a LITTLE bit more emphasis on Kirk and Spock.

But, I'm not really complaining. You and Alex did an amazing, amazing job on Trek.

Noted. Have no intention of having him be a joke.

Bob, are you and Alex going to be doing this "alone" or will you be sharing credit for story and/or screenplay for the second Trek outing? Maybe you don't know yet as you might just be bantering back and forth about an idea first. Which leads to a second question: any studio stipulations on the second film out of the gate?

We will be sharing story credit with the amazing Damon Lindelof, who Produced the first movie with JJ.

Then Alex and I will write the script.

So Bob, as a Trek Fan, what was your favorite species the federation encountered? I myself am a huge Borg fan, but I gotta love the Klingon's style.

Borg for sure.

How's Trek?

Still a twinkle in our eye...

The original posts are here and here and here



More Top StoriesComments
Mar 19Former Actress Robin Curtis is Still Pleased to be Part of the Star Trek Franchise6
Mar 19Read an Excerpt of the Upcoming Star Trek Online Novel The Needs of the Many0
Mar 18Ronald D. Moore Says New Galactica Spin-Off is in Early Stages and It Won't Necessarily Be for TV or a Theatrical Release14
Mar 18Comics Review : Star Trek Movie Adaptation Issue 22
Mar 17Ronald D. Moore Confirms There is a Interest in Continuing the Battlestar Galactica Franchise for SyFy7
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

34 comments Post New | Help
View:

Borg? And Scotty... | Report this post to moderator
By: Kirk Archer (Odo's file, contact) @ 20:48:17 on Oct 06, 2009

I am very glad to hear that Scotty will be less of a caricature and more a serious character. The whole Scotty as comic relief thing started in "The Voyage Home" and has only gotten worse over the years. It's time Scotty returned to being a serious engineer more akin to the way he was portrayed in TOS.

As for the Borg, I think everyone is jumping the gun. Just because Bob Orci says they are his favorite villian doesn't mean they are going to be in the next movie. Sure, there could be some contrived way of bringing them in. But like one of the posters mentions below, let's leave out the Borg, Khan, Q, and/or any other villian or story that's already been done. As mentioned we have the momentum going, let's continue the originality and create something new here. It would be nice to see an Andorian crew member or more such nods to the original series. But let's not rehash that which has already been successfully done.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? | Report this post to moderator
By: StillKirok (Odo's file, contact) @ 11:04:39 on Oct 06, 2009

I can't see it. Even in the original timeline, the Borg only encountered the Federation when they did because Picard smugly mouthed off to Q.

Now, we don't even know if there will BE a Picard, and history has changed so much that the events of Q Who probably won't happen, unless Q is somehow immune to the timeline changes and MAKES them happen.

Either way, the Borg are well beyond reach of the Federation in the 23rd Century.

To bring in the Borg, you would need some being encountered that would be capable of making that happen, LIKE Q (which would suck). Kirk probably DID encounter beings like that, but the first contact with the Borg were introduced to show Picard humility.

Giving Kirk that same lesson would have to dumb him down to Picard's level, and make him look as weak as Picard did in Q Who. Who wants that in a movie?

The way this movie changed the timeline, if anything, the Federation encounters with the Borg would be DELAYED a century, not moved up a century.


Plus, the Berman era, especially post 1994, was an utter failure. Why use anything from that time period as a MAIN antagonist?

Kirk v. the Borg is a cool idea in theory, but I'd only want to see it as it could have been in the PRIME timeline, in a feasible way that probably would have involved a crossover with TNG.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Bucky @ 11:57:39 on Oct 06
    RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by StillKirok @ 12:09:21 on Oct 06
       RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 12:54:52 on Oct 06
          RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by The Magrathean @ 13:12:27 on Oct 06
             RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 13:33:19 on Oct 06
          RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by StillKirok @ 13:12:15 on Oct 06
             RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 13:40:30 on Oct 06
                RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by StillKirok @ 13:46:49 on Oct 06
                   RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 14:05:11 on Oct 06
                      RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by StillKirok @ 14:38:35 on Oct 06
                         RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Kamen Rider Blade @ 15:08:09 on Oct 06
                            RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 16:42:12 on Oct 06
                               RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Kamen Rider Blade @ 22:01:39 on Oct 06
                                  RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Captain's Blog @ 08:47:58 on Oct 07
       RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by katefan @ 12:49:20 on Oct 06
          RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Ichthus @ 13:05:00 on Oct 06

Star Trek XII The Borg ??? | Report this post to moderator
By: GustavoLeao (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 22:23:38 on Oct 05, 2009

So, his favorite villain is the Borg, huh ? I know a lot of people will disagree with me, but I find this extremely interesting. The Abramverse Enterprise against a Borg armada. Sure thing at the box office. Really.

Gustavo

--------

TrekWeb.com Supervising Editor



gl2000@uol.com.br


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by David-Seattle @ 10:37:00 on Oct 06
    RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by The Magrathean @ 11:01:55 on Oct 06
       RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by David-Seattle @ 02:02:55 on Oct 12
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Krazy Joe @ 09:12:10 on Oct 06
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by timmer33 @ 04:43:01 on Oct 06
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by David-Seattle @ 01:02:32 on Oct 06
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by The Magrathean @ 00:36:59 on Oct 06
    RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by seventhstar @ 10:19:44 on Oct 06
       RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by The Magrathean @ 10:37:09 on Oct 06
          RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by seventhstar @ 13:28:08 on Oct 06
             RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by The Magrathean @ 11:37:40 on Oct 07
          RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by GustavoLeao @ 11:20:29 on Oct 06
RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Kamen Rider Blade @ 22:45:57 on Oct 05
    RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by GustavoLeao @ 22:58:03 on Oct 05
       RE: Star Trek XII The Borg ??? by Captain's Blog @ 08:51:44 on Oct 07
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
© 1996-2010 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.