Finally, a producer with the balls to stand up to the "gimme, gimme, gimme" internet fanboy culture. You're supposed to know about the movie when you experience the movie.
Quote:
I bet the theatrical trailer is basically a two minute version of the movie and gives too much away... Trailers should now just feature specially shot footage or maybe cut scenes (or both).
That's actually less the trailer's fault and more the movie's fault. If all the good scenes of a film can be crammed into a 2-minute trailer? (see: Indiana Jones 4) -- then that means your movie is basically the one that should be faulted there...
-- Steve
Quote from JJ Abrams:
"I would argue that not knowing those details in advance is a more refreshing way to live when it comes to entertainment."
Ironically, Team Abrams ignore the Official Star Trek message boards to endorse the very spoiler-peddlers who'll print idle hearsay as fact.
You can't expect to lay with dogs but not get fleas, JJ. ;-)
--------
Windows XP Gets Additional Resuscitation
Faced with either bumping the XP expiration date or letting Linux eat the entire low-cost PC market, Microsoft has chosen to let Vista play the fall guy again.
Get PCLinuxOS
Nemesis, for example, was a bad film, but was made worse by the absolute and relentless dissection of the script prior to release.
Balls to a few impatient fanboys - they can wait and so they should. The film will be so much stronger for it.
JJ is spot on with his handling of this project and I have faith in his judgement.
--------
JamesT
I bet the theatrical trailer is basically a two minute version of the movie and gives too much away... Trailers should now just feature specially shot footage or maybe cut scenes (or both).
--------
"I would be happy for Star Trek to come along decades later with a new group of minds. I'd love someone to say, 'Besides this one, Gene Roddenberry's was nothing!" - Gene Roddenberry, Starburst magazine
Quote:
Frankly, I ruined First Contact for myself by knowing too much about it.
BINGO. That is exactly why I find it so refreshing that J.J. is keeping the jist of Star Trek in a secrecy vault -- a privelage only Star Wars films previously enjoyed. Let's put it this way... waiting for the film in May of 2009 might be a good thing in that you don't want to be the guy who had the ending for Sixth Sense ruined for him. If this is eating at you gentlemen, take up a hobby or something to distract you. :)
-- Steve
Nomore spoilers, thank you. And no need for spoiler warnings when there are no spoilers at all.
Using the food analogy: There are spoilers, and there are appetizers. The former is generally haphazard filler, while the latter is designed to stimulate desire and complement the main meal to come.
Hearsay spoilers are whatever scraps that may be gleaned from a pan or dumpster -- random ingredients which might not be fully baked or properly garnished. They do not represent the completed entree or presentation.
The chef's (Abrams) appetizers can quell the feeling of starvation, whetting the appetite without ruining his feast's pièce de résistance.
Wishful thinking? Movie trailers are one appetizer dish.
Abrams has demonstrated he's a legitimate creative, something of a connoisseur at his craft. He's now also gatekeeper to the Star Trek franchise, with super-sizer access to the goodies vault. There's no practical limit to what he could cook up as fun finger snacks. There has never been more immediate and widespread (Web) multimedia access to popcorn-loving moviegoers.
Come on, JJ, think outside the "mystery box" which fascinates you so. ;-)
--------
Cloverfield (2008) "Scary... Delivers the Thrills."
He is absolutely right... movies are created to have their plots and stories delivered in a certain dramatic context. When you have little tidbits leaked and spoiled here and there, the rabid unknowledgeable fans misinterpret things and jump to conclusions. People can post on here saying certain producers and actors said this and that, to try and stregthen their argument.. "selling it" with hibrow vocabulary.. but what it comes down to is this. 'Star Trek' is JJ Abrams' project to make, not ours, and he has every right to want it delivered to us when it is actually FINISHED.. no matter how rabid a fan some may be. That's not deception, that's good art.
-- Steve
Quote from Jossip.com:
He respects their hunger, but is convinced they are better off waiting...
Abrams doesn't respect that "hunger" when he uses it to bait fans for marketing schemes that advance his agenda.
Without an official go-to source, the thirsty fan will drink whatever koolaid is served by bloggers who seek a sense of power by their own celebrity as a seeming "insider". Walter Koenig recently panned the parasitic "blog personality". Aggressive gossipmongers can make their gullible readers believe there's no other credible source of news.
Get with the program, JJ. Create an informative (and fun) blog under Bad Robot auspices, otherwise just accept that you've already played a role in driving fans to gossip sites which spout hearsay with authority.
--------
Star Trek: Conquest (PS2 | Wii)
Good for Abrams, and for what it's worth, I agree with him. It is certainly a refreshing throwback to the pre-Internet age when spoilers were few and far between. We heard about a movie, read magazine articles a few months before, saw the film, and was pleasantly surprised. Occasionally a spoiler would leak out (pre-released reports of Spock's death in Wrath of Khan was actually the first example of a major "spoiler" I ever encountered), but most of the time you never knew what was coming.
Unfortunately we live in a different time now, one which has developed an entire culture in which spoilers are not just as much a part of the anticipation process as those magazine articles used to be back in 1980-81.
I've already heard some grumblings of the "what are they trying to hide?" variety, plus some have already confused the "code of silence" with the same sort of shorthand "we know this film sucks" that studios use by refusing to allow critics to see the film before release. And you know there are hackers out there who won't sleep until they managed to obtain a leaked script to post to their blogs and forums.
I'm not saying Abrams should cave and allow spoilers. In fact I hope he sticks to his guns till next May. I just hope he's ready for a pretty tough battle over the next 12 months.
Al
A new trailer would be nice though..... =)
--------
"You're going straight in the Army, where you'll be sent straight to America's latest military quagmire. Where will it be? North Korea? Iran? Anything's possible with Commander Koo-Koo Bananas in charge!" --Homer Simpson