menuBarBack
blogging the final frontier since 1996        Beam Up News | Join | Your Account
Home
Schedule
boxBottom
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
Feature Story

Features

Christie Golden's OLD WOUNDS An Excellent VOYAGER Character Study with Little Action

Features

By BWilliams / 12:45, 22 November 2004 / Reviews - Books

Buy now

STAR TREK: VOYAGER - SPIRIT WALK, BOOK 1: OLD WOUNDS
Contributor(s): Christie Golden

Pocket Books MMPB
278 pages

Price: $6.99
Pub Date: November 2003

Buy now from TrekWeb:
3 stars


Synopsis: Captain Chakotay is ready to prove himself as the new commanding officer of the starship Voyager, but skeptics back at Starfleet Command are watching him closely for any sign that he will revert to his renegade Maquis ways…

Review: Last year Christie Golden brought back the crew of the starship Voyager for the first in a series of all-new post-series adventures that showed what happened after the events of the series' final episode 'Endgame"�. Even after combating a Borg virus and a holographic revolution on Earth, it seemed that the crew of the Voyager were headed in different directions. With the latest storyline in the VOYAGER re-launch, Golden is firmly committed to taking the crew into new directions. OLD WOUNDS is the first of a two-part storyline entitled SPIRIT WALK that focuses on the re-launch of Voyager itself and its new captain, Chakotay.

Six months after the events of HOMECOMING and THE FARTHER SHORE, Chakotay is ready to get underway as the new commanding officer of Voyager. The only familiar face from the old Voyager crew is Harry Kim, who has now been promoted to lieutenant and is now in Tuvok's old position as security chief. Most everyone else on the ship is new. Chakotay's new first officer, Andrew Ellis, is a 30-year-old stuck-up loner with a penchant for snobbish behavior, despite his extremely dedicated work ethic. Chakotay's younger sister Sekaya has come aboard as Voyager's spiritual advisor, and Dr. Jarem Kaz, a joined Trill, has signed on as Voyager's new chief medical officer, replacing the now obsolete Emergency Medical Hologram.

Fate has been as less kind to Voyager's former crewmen. Admiral Janeway and her advisor, Tuvok, have sought out Tom Paris, vacationing with his wife B'Elanna Torres on the Klingon monastery world of Boreth, to consider a new job as a starship first officer. The EMH faces a continual backlash of hatred and racism because of his holographic origins, a ripple effect from the holographic wars in THE FARTHER SHORE. And on Voyager, Harry Kim struggles to maintain a balance between his career and his strained relationship with his girlfriend Libby Webber.

Golden has an excellent grasp of all of the characters' personalities, fleshing each person out as relatable to our own. Among the new characters, the attractive Sekaya is the most interesting in my opinion because of her role as Voyager's spiritual advisor. Her background, falling in line with Chakotay's, presents her as the most appealing of the new characters, and what male wouldn't want to find himself spending time with Sekaya? Andrew Ellis, the ship's new first officer, comes off as priggish and snobbish, maintaining very few, if any, interpersonal relationships and earning him the well-deserved nickname Priggy in the process. Chakotay takes it upon himself to loosen Ellis up and make him a part of the Voyager crew, even indulging the young first officer in a game of Wimbledon-style tennis. And Jarem Kaz undergoes his own spiritual journey, setting things right with Kaz' previous host Gradak.

But excellent character personalities cannot make up for what is obviously the weaker part of OLD WOUNDS, its core story at hand. Golden's pacing of the main story, the Voyager's mission to Loran II to render aid and assistance to its inhabitants, is extremely slow, with almost nothing in the first two-thirds of the book to keep the pace going. Perhaps that is why I had trouble with OLD WOUNDS, there was no major plot from the outset to keep my interest going for the most part. However, in true fashion, the action does not begin to get underway until the book's final chapter, setting up the events to follow in SPIRIT WALK's concluding chapter, ENEMY OF MY ENEMY, coming in December.

For now, SPIRIT WALK: OLD WOUNDS covers the characters' main problems spot on, as each character has his or her old wounds to come to terms with. It's a good character study with very little in the way of plot and action. Let's hope that ENEMY OF MY ENEMY turns things around for the better.

TrekWeb's Rating Scale
A Must Read
Recommended
Average
Mediocre
Don't Bother


More Top StoriesComments
Sep 073-D Look at Box Art for TOS Remastered DVD Season 3 Box Set 8
Sep 06Nicole de Boer Says She Would Love to Appear in J.J. Abrams Star Trek Movie8
Sep 06J.J. Abrams Talks X-Files, Galactica, Star Trek and Fringe3
Sep 05Zachary Quinto Compares the Characters of Sylar and Spock  0
Sep 05Star Trek Mirror Universe Shards and Shadows Anthology Book Details0
Story Archives...Browse:   
Recent Reviews
Nov 9Enterprise Crew Finds DUTY, HONOR, REDEMPTION in New Signature Edition Compilation0
Nov 8THE HAND OF KAHLESS is Pocket's Latest Signature Edition Compilation0
Nov 4Picard & Co. Meet Their MAKER in Latest STARGAZER Novel by Michael Jan Friedman0
Oct 26Keith R.A. DeCandido Ends NEXT GEN Saga With A TIME FOR WAR, A TIME FOR PEACE8
Oct 8The NEXT GENERATION Crew Experiences A TIME TO HEAL in Latest Novel by David Mack0
More Reviews...

Talkback

5 comments Post New | Help
View:

Voyager Novels | Report this post to moderator
By: GustavoLeao (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 20:50:44 on Nov 22, 2004

Good review. I am enjoying the Voyager Homecoming books and plan to get Old Wounds next month. I really wish Paramount could have done those stories as Voyager TV movies. Chakotay as captain of the USS Voyager is great and I am sure Beltran would have loved the part.

Gustavo


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

??? | Report this post to moderator
By: EntFan! (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 17:19:13 on Nov 22, 2004

I actually enjoyed both novels. They were something of an intrigue to me and in my opinion would probably make one hell of a movie. The action was slow, agreed, but all I've heard from people is "too much action, not enough character development"...well guys, here's the character development...My personal rating would be a 4.5 out of 5 stars...

--------

"Being A Jackass Is Not A Talent, It's A Science"


...Quoted By Me While Passed Out Drunk




"Live Hard, Die Young, And Leave A Good Looking Corpse!"


--Kindred: The Embraced


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: ??? by Gitch @ 20:06:53 on Nov 22
    RE: ??? by EntFan! @ 22:25:11 on Nov 22
       RE: ??? by icedtea @ 04:11:04 on Dec 05
Promenade










TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!
Privacy Policy | About Us | Legal Notice | Contact Us | | Get Firefox!
© 1996-2007 TrekWeb.com and Steve Krutzler. All rights reserved.