Home Home Leftcorner_menuBack menuBarBack
Community News Features About Us
Home | Submit News | Join | Your Account
Schedule
boxBottom
Advanced Search
boxBottom
News Tribblets
boxBottom
Stardates Calendar
Feature Story

Features

STAR TREK: GENERATIONS a Nexus of Shock and Awe on Collector's Edition DVD

Features

By Steve Krutzler / 03:48, 27 August 2004 / Reviews - Products

Buy now

STAR TREK: GENERATIONS Collector's Edition
DVD

Price: $13.99
Pub Date: September 2004

Buy now from TrekWeb

3 stars


Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Image

Two captains, one destiny.

Well, not quite. STAR TREK: GENERATIONS seems born of several destinies, beginning with two competing scripts, including two popular casts, and layering together a broad range of thematic elements. The seventh STAR TREK feature has long been at the center of the disdain many have for the hit and miss ST:TNG films, but of the four, GENERATIONS is surprisingly the most watchable.

The new Collector's Edition DVD, hitting U.S. shelves on the eve of STAR TREK's 38th Anniversary, provides plenty of opportunity to examine why. It's a film rife with problems, from incoherent plot devices to bad lines and recycled pryotechnics. There are more gimmicks thrown into the film's near-two hours than even a Ferengi can keep up with. Klingons and sailors and Christmas trees, oh my, the script is a mishmash of creative energies. There are also blatant plot problems, like the concept of the Nexus, which invites more plot holes than you can imagine, contrived as a way to avoid using time travel to bring Kirk and Picard together. How exactly does one "think" their way out of the Nexus, anyway? You're better off not to ask such questions, but despite this caveat, GENERATIONS is still a lot of fun to watch.

One reason is the late John Alonzo's spectacular photography. It may be strange that the vacuum of space bathes the interior of the Enterprise-D in golden light, but it's sure pretty to look at. It also helps hide the lack of detail in the surfaces of the television sets, all except engineering looking better than they ever have. The warp core's flat, featureless face definitely needed a facelift for the big screen, but overall the Enterprise we came to know and love for seven years received a beautiful treatment in this film. The look of the film is also helped by a lot of color, perhaps lacking in the rest of the TNG films, in part due to the black and gray uniforms that FIRST CONTACT ushered in. At first it strikes of laziness for the crew to be interchanging between the TNG and DS9 costumes rather than having unique and consistent new threads, but the bold colors really make the frames of this picture a feast for the eye, and the familiarity of the style contributes to the happy feeling you get while watching, even if the script starts to drown about midway through.

The other big factor for me has always been Dennis McCarthy's original score. Second to my personal favorite, STAR TREK VI, McCarthy's score makes GENERATIONS the only TNG movie that I'll regularly watch through to the very last credit. Completely original and lacking the rehash that plagues FIRST CONTACT through NEMESIS, McCarthy's sweeping cues elevate the picture in many instances and never make the mistake of becoming mere wallpaper to the striking visuals. Highlights include the eerie Soran/intro pieces, the space battle, and the grandiose main theme that'll ring in your head for days. The only real let down is the Nexus music, disappointing mostly because the sequence as a whole just drags the film to a halt.

Despite warp-speed traveling rockets, confusing plot developments (such as Picard's volunteering to become a prisoner but then being immediately beamed down to the planet's surface), and a heavily contrived method of uniting Picard and Kirk, GENERATIONS still succeeds with some key elements. Namely, the scenes with William Shatner and the other representatives of the original crew, and Shatner's interactions with Patrick Stewart. The fact is that GENERATIONS goes into the hearts of both our captains and while the sentimental approach may not have been the best strategy for huge success at the box office, it's a really enjoyable ride for STAR TREK fans. We see a whole new side of Kirk and the look at his life that could've been is entirely appropriate for what would become the character's ultimate swan song, and a movie that tries desperately to deal with the issue of mortality. Having the swashbuckling heroes reexamine their choices as mortality creeps in is a poignant subtext to the "passing of the baton" credo permeating of the pic.

Data's comic subplot delights with groans and all. From the bad jokes to the "oh, shit," Spiner imbues all his scenes with successful humor and his journey across the gamut of human emotions provides an interesting subplot. Data and Geordi's relationship from the television series gets the most screen time in this movie (nearly forgotten in the others) and his emotional scene with Picard in stellar cartography - another example of rich, bright, pleasing color - is in the finest tradition of what STAR TREK was always about: the continuing exploration of the human condition. Add to that a marquee action sequence in the saucer crash landing (aka the scene so nice they used it twice), and you've got plenty of set pieces to keep the piece afloat.

The Commentaries

Co-writers Brannon Braga and Ronald D. Moore provide the play-by-play this time around, in a satisfyingly candid audio commentary track. Their discussion ranges from the early stages of development to little things like costuming, to outright criticism of their own work. Moore states that their inexperience as writers at the time contributed, and they both agree that meeting the demands the studio had for the script and pleasing everyone else along the way just made for a difficult writing process.

Braga and Moore explain the difficulties in working each character into the picture, such as finding a good way to utilize Troi and the mistake of having Picard become too emotional in his big screen debut. As the film progresses, both writers point out several blatant errors in the script and things they wished they could've worked out better. Braga points out something I've never managed to notice, which is the fact that Picard tells Worf "that's a pretty big margin of error" after Worf explains the odds of shooting down Soran's probe; obviously this should be "a pretty small" margin, not a large one.

Once the film gets into the Nexus, the commentary becomes pretty candid, from admitting that the idea of the Nexus itself wasn't very well-defined and invited numerous plot holes, to displeasure with the having introduced Captain Kirk doing, of all things, chopping wood and scrambling eggs. They admit that the inclusion of horseback riding was intentionally to attract Shatner and offer funny anecdotes like the fact that Shatner let the production use his horses for the sequence, but charged the studio for it! We also learn that much of Shatner's dialogue while walking his horse around Stewart was rewritten and replaced after the shoot.

By the end of the commentary, both Moore and Braga conclude that the performances of Stewart, Shatner, Spiner, McDowell, and the rest of the cast elevated the material beyond the page and that several of the film's misfires were the result of directly trying to avoid cliché and do things different. It seems that the proximity of the writing and production process to the seven year TNG series - both made for all intents and purposes, concurrently - actually made it difficult identify the types of elements that might've played better in a feature film.

Mike and Denise Okuda's text commentary comes in big STAR TREK-styled pop-ups, bringing you a mix of mundane, obvious, and mildly informative for the non-initiated observations or trivia facts about the picture. The main difference from previous Collector's Edition products is that they pop up on top of the film image, making it less attractive to run the commentary at all because you can't see the picture half the time and what's in the pop-up box isn't particularly compelling. Paramount would be wise to put these pop-ups in the black space below the letterbox from now on.


Continued...
 of 3.    Next >


More Top StoriesComments
Sep 073-D Look at Box Art for TOS Remastered DVD Season 3 Box Set 8
Sep 06Nicole de Boer Says She Would Love to Appear in J.J. Abrams Star Trek Movie8
Sep 06J.J. Abrams Talks X-Files, Galactica, Star Trek and Fringe3
Sep 05Zachary Quinto Compares the Characters of Sylar and Spock  0
Sep 05Star Trek Mirror Universe Shards and Shadows Anthology Book Details0
Story Archives...Browse:   

Talkback

42 comments Post New | Help
View:

CAN ANYONE STILL FIND GENERATIONS??? | Report this post to moderator
By: PainBot5000 (Odo's file, contact) @ 13:03:39 on Sep 13, 2004

Hey I was jsut woindering if anyone knew a place that might still be selling the Generations DVD, i heard people where still getting them at Borders but couldn't find one there when I went. Just wondering. Thanks.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

I remember seeing the Giordi Interrogation | Report this post to moderator
By: chemistrylover (Odo's file, contact) @ 01:46:23 on Aug 30, 2004

I know this is really weird. When I saw Generations in 1994, I distinctly remember seeing the Giordi interrogation scene. Soran wasn't causing pain to Giordi's heart, he was stopping it. I know for a fact that this wasn't a test screening, because I saw it on the Sunday of its opening weekend. I remember this scene was in the movie and that Kirk was not shot in the back. Could it be that the print that I saw at the theatre was somehow altered compared to the standard print that everyone else saw? I remember when the movie came out on Laserdisk that that scene was not in there (or on the tape either) and asking myself what happened to that scene.

The scene really fit in well with the movie since Soran saying "his heart just wasn't in it" was actually a pretty cruel irony after seeing him stop and start it a couple of times with that Borg Nanoprobe.

Anyway, I also remember that LeVar was completely naked during this scene (but they didn't show it) and that the camera went well below his waistline, almost to where his pubes would start being at the bottom of the screen. Could this be why the scene was cut, if the camera showed too much of LeVar?

Is it possible that this scene was in the final cut, but removed at a later date because of too much skin being shown by a man?

Anyway, I am positive that I saw this scene in the theater, so tell me, can anyone else remember seeing it?


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: I remember seeing the Giordi Interrogation by Josh Cohen @ 14:30:51 on Sep 01
    RE: I remember seeing the Giordi Interrogation by chemistrylover @ 03:43:49 on Sep 02
RE: I remember seeing the Giordi Interrogation by BWilliams @ 16:08:54 on Aug 30

Golden light | Report this post to moderator
By: Cyrus (Odo's file, contact) @ 04:27:33 on Aug 28, 2004

Quote:
It may be strange that the vacuum of space bathes the interior of the Enterprise-D in golden light, but it’s sure pretty to look at.

It has been a while since I saw Generations, but I think they were close to some star at the time (Amargosa Star?). So the golden light was coming from the star, not the vacuum of space.

--------

Good manners, madam, are never a waste of time.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Golden light by Steve Krutzler @ 13:13:36 on Aug 28
    RE: Golden light by TrekGuy 001 @ 04:46:19 on Aug 29
    RE: Golden light by Cyrus @ 16:15:30 on Aug 28
       RE: Golden light by Darth Brooks @ 22:50:42 on Aug 28

Boy, did we see different movies... | Report this post to moderator
By: dx31701 (Odo's file, contact) @ 00:20:51 on Aug 28, 2004

Quote:
It may be strange that the vacuum of space bathes the interior of the Enterprise-D in golden light, but it’s sure pretty to look at.

What was strange here is that the lighting was so drastically different than we saw for seven years. I don't know that I agree that the lighting was well done - much of the time it just looked like they simply had the lights off on the ship.

Quote:
McCarthy’s sweeping cues elevate the picture in many instances and never make the mistake of becoming mere wallpaper to the striking visuals.

Gotta disagree here, too. Yes, it had a nice theme with some rousing instances of the courage fanfare, but much of the score was the same old "wallpaper" that Berman seems to like for the TV shows. This was not a score that was really well thought through, where the music enhances the themes and becomes a storyteller and a character. This was background music that was ocassionally reasonably good, but mostly just there.

Quote:
The fact is that GENERATIONS goes into the hearts of both our captains and while the sentimental approach may not have been the best strategy for huge success at the box office, it’s a really enjoyable ride for STAR TREK fans. We see a whole new side of Kirk and the look at his life that could’ve been is entirely appropriate for what would become the character’s ultimate swan song, and a movie that tries desperately to deal with the issue of mortality. Having the swashbuckling heroes reexamine their choices as mortality creeps in is a poignant subtext to the “passing of the baton” credo permeating of the pic.

This "sentimental approach" was terrible for STAR TREK fans - i.e. for people who know these characters well. This approach to Kirk and the look at mortality was an unoriginal rehash - done and done again in previous movies. TMP - Kirk has been pulled away from the bridge and is desparate to get her back. TWOK - Kirk has been pulled away from the bridge and is desparate to get her back and faces mortality in a very real way. GEN - same ol' rehash. Doesn't this character grow? Doesn't he adjust and adapt as life changes? Yet again, Kirk can't adjust to life outside that chair.

Then, "establishing" that Kirk's greatest need in life is to be a starship Captain and to "make a difference" (I thought he wanted to explore the universe, not be a hero), we are shown that Kirk's greatest fantasy, in this Nexus that gives you what you want so badly that you never want to leave, is chores? cooking? Some woman that the audience has never seen, who Kirk is happy to drop for a horseride? Ridiculous.

In GEN Kirk becomes a throwaway character who doesn't grow - he doesn't overcome that debilitating need to be on the bridge. He doesn't learn to live life in it's next configuration. He just gets a chance to return to what the writers claim he needs - "making a difference." And then he falls off a bridge. This icon of a show and a genre and pop-culture ends up being nothing more than a catalyst for character development for Picard, and is subsequently thrown away.

There are at least two great mis-characterizations of Kirk in Star Trek that just completely get the character wrong. One is "Requeim for Methuselah" in which this Kirk, who is committed to Enterprise "with no beach to walk on" is ready to throw it all away to be with the android woman. The other is Star Trek Generations.

The characterization of Picard is less "wrong", but a definite miscalculation in terms of effective drama or storytelling. It feels forced, rather than flowing from what we know of the character, and the need to continue through offspring had been sufficiently explored on TNG.

As for Data - completely ineffective in terms of humor, completely out of place for the tone of the movie, the "shark jump" beginning the ruination of a great TNG character - the push in a downward slide which resulted in nobody even caring that Data bites it in Nemesis.

Generations is a failure as Star Trek, and barely adequate as a film.


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

Generations deleted scenes/bloopers | Report this post to moderator
By: John Clark (Odo's file, contact) @ 13:21:02 on Aug 27, 2004

I hope they include the blooper where Shatner shows up at the Valley Of Fire set & says "Goddam, who smells like ass?!?"


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

Hmmm.... | Report this post to moderator
By: Jadzia-Dax (Odo's file, contact) @ 11:12:46 on Aug 27, 2004

An interesting review to say the least. I think it comes down to being somewhat "non-committal". Image

Ie., a "compromising" review for a film filled with "compromises".

I think anyone who has seen me post comments on this movie knows from whence I come from with respect to it. There is some incredible music here and moreso, incredible effects, from the opening sequence with the bottle spinning in space, where as it comes closer to the audience, you can finally read the label to realize it was a bottle of "Dom Perrignon"... To the unbelieveable saucer crash sequence, something that I sat in a packed theater to see (one that had a sold-out crowd at a 1:30pm or thereabouts showing on the opening Friday in 1994). And as the audience braced itself for what was to come, all one could do was hold on as that massive saucer hit the ground in full Dolby Surround glory. And when it was all said and done, the audience literally sat there STUNNED in silence and awe. And it was good to know that the model for that was 12ft long because I figured it HAD to be big to get that kind of detail and massiveness displayed on camera.

And ever since, I had tried to recapture the power of that scene - first with the VHS (lol) and Dolby Prologic, and finally with an expensive upgrade to create a home theater including a brandy new laser disk player back then (a Denon) to be able to get the LD Dolby Digital AC3 version of GEN. At which point, with the addition of a powered subwoofer, pots and pans would rattle on their shelves in the kitchen, which shared a wall with the system. ;-)

The sad thing is that as I quickly discovered, the pan and scan VHS release had footage cut, not only from the actual saucer crash, but from other scenes that fully used the widescreen format (eg., some of the Lursa and B'Etor stuff).

But other than that in this film... Sigh. Kirk dead. Picard's Nexus sequence totally inconsistent with the character, Data sadly annoying, Borg knowledge now introduced back into Kirk's time (and if anyone believes that the El-Aurien refugess would keep their reasons for being refugees from the Borg "secret", is pandering to ENT syndrome), yadda yadda.

If anything, it will be interesting to see Moore and Braga's comments as I have seen some in written interviews recently. And I might even do a side-by-side check of the DVD vs the LD, but because my DVD now has a component video hook-up, I may not be able to put the LD in a PIP on the TV and play both simultaneously based on how my TV does the video options. I'll see.

--------

"I think the show talked to people through the characters. They're stories that speak to the heart. They talk about love, they talk about friendship, they talk about loyalty, they talk about patriotism, exploration, curiosity, reaching out... And I think all those things still touch people. Even when you look at a 30-year old show, it still has something to say." - D.C. Fontana, Sci Fi Channel Special Edition TOS 1998

----

"If the season finale involves the re-built USS Reliant coming back in time to the 21st Century crewed by Moogie, Dr. Selar, Morn, Transporter Chief Kyle, and the Salt Vampire, then we'll know that Coto has gone too far." - tomba1701


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Hmmm.... by Steve Krutzler @ 11:29:31 on Aug 27
    RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 13:49:50 on Aug 27
       RE: Hmmm.... by steveleenow @ 18:28:53 on Aug 30
       RE: Hmmm.... by Merlinus Ambrosius @ 19:31:29 on Aug 27
          RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 19:46:32 on Aug 27
       RE: Hmmm.... by Cap'n Calhoun @ 15:38:01 on Aug 27
          RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 18:04:13 on Aug 27
             RE: Hmmm.... by Cap'n Calhoun @ 03:59:41 on Aug 28
                RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 11:32:58 on Aug 28
                   RE: Hmmm.... by Cap'n Calhoun @ 17:07:27 on Aug 28
                      RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 22:38:12 on Aug 28
                         RE: Hmmm.... by Cap'n Calhoun @ 02:31:18 on Aug 29
                            RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 08:50:23 on Aug 29
       RE: Hmmm.... by Steve Krutzler @ 13:59:36 on Aug 27
          RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 18:15:21 on Aug 27
             RE: Hmmm.... by Steve Krutzler @ 18:20:17 on Aug 27
                RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 19:27:27 on Aug 27
                   RE: Hmmm.... by Steve Krutzler @ 19:37:56 on Aug 27
                      RE: Hmmm.... by Jadzia-Dax @ 20:13:32 on Aug 27

Awesome! | Report this post to moderator
By: Meglo (Odo's file, contact) @ 09:47:15 on Aug 27, 2004

I've been looking forward to this ever since they announced the Collector's Editions. I may actually delay getting it until Christmas, though, just because GEN is sort of tied to the holiday for me.

--------

"We claim that picnic area in the name of the Klingon Empire!"- PvPOnline, 9/2/04


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

Um... | Report this post to moderator
By: Darth Brooks (Odo's file, contact) @ 09:24:07 on Aug 27, 2004

A golden shower, Steve?

Seriously?

:-o


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: Um... by Steve Krutzler @ 16:21:23 on Aug 27
    RE: Um... by Darth Brooks @ 19:21:40 on Aug 27

Hmm ... | Report this post to moderator
By: jstewart_2k3 (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 08:29:45 on Aug 27, 2004

Quote:
The seventh STAR TREK feature has long been at the center of the disdain many have for the hit and miss ST:TNG films, but of the four, GENERATIONS is surprisingly the most watchable.

I thought Insurrection was to be blamed for why TNG movies aren't considered that good. Regardless, I agree with this comment, despite First Contact being my favourite of the TNG movies I find myself more drawn to watching Generation, mostly for the interaction between Kirk and Picard and the scenes aboard the Enterprise-B. I didn't find the Data sub-plot as tiresome as most did, but I didn't like the way Picard was treated although it did serve to give some insight into Soran.

--------

"I can't think of one right now, please check and try again."


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

No Trailers ? | Report this post to moderator
By: GustavoLeao (Odo's file, contact, web site) @ 08:13:20 on Aug 27, 2004

The disappointing thing is that neither the teaser or full trailer are included. Can you believe this ? Damn Paramount !

THE MOTION PICTURE and THE FINAL FRONTIER SE DVDs even has those various tv ads from the movies. And GENERATIONS has this cool tv ad with a scene in which Kirk tells Captain John Harriman "Let's cheat death together !". This deleted scene is also not include in the DVD. C'mon !

Well, I love GENERATIONS, it is my favorite TNG movie, so I can't wait to order this SPECIAL EDITION. But no trailers ? That's pretty inexcusable.

Anyway, awesome review, Steve !

Gustavo


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote

good review | Report this post to moderator
By: Alawi (Odo's file, contact) @ 05:54:07 on Aug 27, 2004

Steve excellent review as always.

Pity the deleted scenes are rough and nothing new was inserted into the actual film (a la TUC).


Reply
Reply
Quote
Quote
RE: good review by hawkeye @ 12:14:42 on Sep 01
RE: good review by BringBackKirk @ 07:55:18 on Aug 27
    RE: good review by Kirk Archer @ 14:36:56 on Aug 27
Promenade



ST:DS9 Season Seven DVD




TrekWeb Merchants
Amazon.com
Amazon.co.uk
Amazon.ca
Amazon.de
Barnes & Noble

Get Firefox!